Worth noting: I agree with reviewers that they run small. I chose the larger of the sizes I’m between, and my heel hit right at the edge of the shoe. And because they just barely fit my feet, the strap dug in when I tried to put it behind my ankle.
Product specs
Sizes: US 5 to 12 | Colors: 6 | Material: Suede, EVA foam
Original image by commerce writer Jessica Kasparian
Original image by commerce writer Jessica Kasparian
Steve Madden Ledger Black Leather
Pros
Cons
- Creases easily
- Not great for sweaty feet
Cute clogs aren’t always comfortable—thankfully, this pair from Steve Madden checks both boxes. “I have high arches and was pretty impressed by how supportive and lightweight they are,” one SELF editor says. “I tested them in 90-degree summer weather and noticed that my feet did sweat inside a little—since they’re all faux leather (even in the footbed), they’re not very breathable. But as I wear these into fall and winter, I don’t think this will be a big issue.”
Also good to know: “The upper creased almost immediately after I tried them on—so if you like the broken-in look, you’ll love these,” our tester says. “The buckle is surprisingly high-quality too.”
Product specs
Sizes: US 5 to 12 | Colors: 2 | Material: Leather
Original image by senior commerce editor Sarah Felbin
Original image by senior commerce editor Sarah Felbin
Rothy’s The Casual Clog
Pros
- Feels like slippers
- Comes in lots of colors
Cons
- Not great for longer walks
Rothy’s has always been about comfy footwear, so when they dropped their take on a clog, we had to give them a try. “Every time I wear these outside, I feel like I’m getting away with something—but yes, even though they look like slippers, they are indeed outside shoes!” one SELF editor says.
They’re made with Merino wool or hemp, depending on the style you choose, which gives them that cozy, casual look. But their rubber bottom makes them durable, for hitting the pavement. “I’m a fan of the roomy toe box and the insole’s mid-height arch that hits my foot at the right spot to support my former-dancer feet,” our editor says.
FYI: They’re not ideal for power walking, she explains. “When I pick up the pace, sometimes I step right out of the clog; so I stick to sneakers if I’m running errands or bopping around town and slip these on for quickie dog walks and casual strolls.”
Product specs
Sizes: US 5 to 13 | Colors: 10 | Material: Merino wool or hemp, recycled plastic bottles
Kidmi Suede Clogs
Pros
- Wide size range
- Variety of colors
- Budget-friendly
Cons
- Some reviewers say they’re hard to keep clean
Amazon always comes in clutch with trendy dupes, so I wasn’t surprised to find a sleek Boston lookalike on the site. These Kidmi shoes stand out because they have a super similar silhouette, thanks to their suede upper and worn-in buckle. But regardless of how they look in photos, I’d only consider buying shoes with a great rating and tons of fans—thankfully, this pair fits the bill, with over 2,200 five-star reviews.
